On Yom Kippur day, just 4 days ago, I took a long walk around Jerusalem and on the way stopped at various places - one of which was the free
Gilad Shalit protest tent in front of the Prime Minister's house. Gilad Shalit is an Israeli who was kidnapped by
Hamas terrorists more than 5 years ago. He has been held captive in Gaza with no contact with the outside world (this includes no allowed visits from the International Red Cross...).
|
Gilad Shalit's tent. The chair in the center reads: Reserved for Gilad Shalit. This tent is just part of a whole protest area that lines the entire block in front of the Prime Minister's house, ironically on "Gaza Street." (photo linked from israelitkan.ning.com) |
| | | | | | | | | | | |
|
When I arrived the mid-day the tent was empty except for a young mother and her inquisitive daughter - about 5 years old or so. The conversation I overheard between is one that I'll never forget.
"Imma, what is this tent here for?"
"It is a tent that is for Gilad Shalit, an Israeli soldier who was taken away by a bad army"
"Why did they take him? Did he do something bad?"
"No he didn't do something, they took him because he was Israeli and a soldier"
"Why do they not like Israelis?"
"... It's had to explain..."
"... who sits here in these chairs if he isn't here?"
"His mommy and daddy and family sit here waiting for him, and that chair is for Gilad when he comes home (she points to an empty chair in the center of the tent with a sign on it stating "Reserved for Gilad Shalit")"
"When will he come home?"
"I don't know, sweetie"
My heart broke overhearing this. How does one explain such a complicated, emotional, devastating issue and concept in general to a little girl. I just stood there staring at the dozens of posters of Gilad lining the upper area and teared up.
--
Why is Gilad a big deal?
On one hand, Gilad is
just one person. On the other hand, he's a person. He's also an Israeli soldier.
He has come to represent much more than himself in Israel and the global Jewish community. He is representative of every person who serves in the Israel Defense Force (most of the country's Jewish population).
He represents everyone's sons and daughters, sisters and brothers, partners, parents, and friends. With a mandatory conscription at age 18 and reserve duty continuing on for decades more, in a country that is constantly in some state of war, Israelis
need to believe that their country will be behind them if they, themselves were to be in Gilad's horrible situation.
In this way Gilad's hopeful return is more than just the return of 1 Israeli citizen- it is a return of Gilad to his family and to the nation as he has become "everyone's son" (this phrase used often in the news). It is also the reassurance of faith in the State of Israel's commitment to the protection of its citizens.
Fastforward to last night (October 11, 2011)...
According to the news the Israeli negotiators have struck a deal with Hamas! In exchange for Gilad's release Israel will release more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners, nearly half terrorists and some convicted murderers. Nonetheless the Israeli government negotiators seem to believe that this is the best deal that they could have gotten.
Like many in the country I was elated and emotional hearing this news. Gilad's family and supporters across the world have been protesting and pressuring the Israeli government to find a way to free him since his capture.
Objectively speaking- whoa, what a conundrum.
Personally speaking - whoa, what a conundrum.
In order to free Gilad Israel not only had to negotiate with terrorists but also free thousands of prisoners, many of whom will likely go on to cause further harm to Israelis in the future. Catch 22.
|
A memorial plaque for the victims of a suicide bombing that took place in this place in March 2002 (left). It is just across the street from the Shalit tent. |
With that said I'm personally torn. The deal, on paper, is totally unbalanced and some even say reckless on Israel's part. However, I would say that there was no choice, and like I explained earlier, this was about much more than one person, it was about the whole country. And yet, it was still just about one person- this says a lot about Israel's character. And if it were my family, I'd want the same. What a day!
Here's what it looked like outside the Shalit tent today
Chag Sukkot Sameach. May Gilad's return to his family and Israel be quick as possible.